10-02-2009
Permalink
|
Subject: Hey Kids, I've Got A Message For You ...
From the RFK Record,
No Community Immunity
by Heather Marie Mendez:
"It's time to talk about community service.
We all know you've heard about it a million times and that you
have to complete at least 200 hours to receive a diploma and
graduate; well this year it's no joke.
Prior to this year, the alumni of Robert F Kennedy Community High
School took community service lightly and didn't always complete
their hours; the administration was lenient and allowed students
to graduate, but the buck stops here.
Some students are disgruntled about the recent announcement.
"If students from years before were able to graduate and didn't
complete all their hours, it's not fair that the same policies
do not apply to us," said Hawa Faiq, sophomore.
On the contrary, some students seem un-phased by the new enforced
policy.
"I've always known that I had to do all 200 hours so it's not a
big deal to me; community service is a good thing and it looks
great on college applications," said junior Daoud Noori.
So if you're feeling inspired, it's time to sign up for walks,
participate in school activities and talk to Mrs. Henry or Mrs.
Lang to make sure you get those hours done and those time sheets
filled out.
Remember, you won't get your diploma without it. So RFK, it's
time to get serious; get inspired, help your community, and
complete those 200 hours!"
I was particularly taken by the absolutely fantastic "teachable
moment" when the clueless student, Hawa Faiq, points out that
there is something unfair about selectively enforcing a policy upon
him when others are given a free pass, and Ms. Mendez counters
with, "On the contrary, some students seem un-phased by the new
enforced policy." You simply cannot counter a syllogism like
this, and must bend to its powerful logic! So much for Hawa Faiq,
who is clearly not representative of the type of student RFK is
designed to produce. Maybe he will have learned his lesson and not
attempt to question authority in the future by applying the outmoded
use of reason. Or more hopefully, as a sophomore, he might escape
from RFK's clutches for the remaining two years of his high school
education.
I am also pretty sure that Ms. Mendez's use of the phrase, "the
buck stops here" isn't really apropos to the point she was
attempting to make!
Here is the response I posted to the article at the RFK site:
"Hey kids, I have a somewhat different message for you.
The United States Constitution (did you ever study that is
school?) guarantees each of us the right to our life, liberty
and property. Yes, it's true! Right there in the Fifth
Amendment, it states:
"No person shall be [...] deprived of life, liberty, or
property, without due process of law"
Well, according to the Constitution, your "life" is yours, to do
with as you see fit. This means that you -- and you alone --
decide the goals you wish to pursue. And your "liberty" is the
freedom to act independently, based upon your own judgment. It
seems to me that your parents, teachers, school administrators,
politicians, and Ms. Mendez may have all forgotten this. Maybe
you should remind them, and let them know that you do not delegate
to them, the authority to determine the course of your life.
And, of course, there is that other pesky amendment #13 which
states:
"Neither slavery nor involuntary servitude, except as a
punishment for crime whereof the party shall have been duly
convicted, shall exist within the United States, or any place
subject to their jurisdiction."
Kids, what do you think slavery and "involuntary servitude" mean
in this context? Do you think that forcing every child to
complete 200 hours of community service in order for them to
pursue their education qualifies? How do you feel about this?
It's one thing to allow students to truly volunteer for any
activity that they find worthwhile, but to require you to perform
these services -- to use force to compel those of you to
participate when you would otherwise elect not to do so --
doesn't that seem to qualify as involuntary servitude and
violate your individual rights? It certainly does to me.
And on a more practical note, if you were not being forced to
spend your time on these community service activities, you might
instead invest those hours in an after school job. The minimum
wage is currently $7.25/hour, so the time that your school forces
you to work for the community amounts to a minimum of $1,450.00.
Maybe you should send them a bill!
Some people think that performing community service will make you
a more well rounded person and a better citizen. Maybe, maybe not.
Personally, I think that any endeavor you pursue that teaches you
to use reason, develop your analytical skills, think for yourself
and challenge authority, are activities of considerably more value
to your personal development, and would certainly make you be the
type of person that I would welcome into my community.
Give it some thought. And if you are interested in a more
in-depth analysis of this subject, check out my writings at:
So kids, I send each of you my best for a long and successful
life. And for those of you reading this who see that there is
another side to this issue of mandatory service, I encourage you
to stand up for your rights. They are valuable, and if you
preserve them, they will serve you well.
Regards,
--
C. Jeffery Small"
The comment is awaiting approval. What are the chances that they
will post it?
[PostScript: Well, after sending two follow-up comments regarding
the site owner's failure to publish my comments, I was shocked to
see the comment finally displayed on 10-09-09, a full week after it was
originally submitted. Of course, the delay means that few people will
see the comment, but I guess it's better late than never!]
|